What Should I Play?

A website that helps you decide what video game to play next based on your playstyle and preferences.

Welcome to "What Should I Play?"!

Here’s a brief rundown of the categories:

  • Casual – Easier & relaxing games; you're playing to chill out!
  • Competitive – Multiplayer games; test your skills against others!
  • Story-based – Narrative-focused; immerse yourself in rich storytelling!
  • Hardcore – Challenging games; test your limits!
  • Play with friends – Co-op & multiplayer; enjoy gaming together!

Top 10 Games of the Past 10 Years

The top 10 games listed are based on Metacritic's Metascore ratings. All rankings support all console platforms and PC.

10. Persona 5 Royal

Everything good about the original, with even more content.

Persona 5 Royal rounds out the list with its stylish presentation, memorable characters, and engaging blend of life simulation and dungeon crawling. While it remains an outstanding RPG, its status as an enhanced version of an earlier release places it at the lower end of this decade ranking despite its quality.

9. Hades II

Somehow, it's even better than the first one!

Hades II builds on the strengths of its predecessor with refined gameplay and expanded narrative elements. It delivers a compelling and polished experience, though as a newer title, it hasn’t yet had the same long-term impact as others above it.

8. Portal: Companion Collection

Two award-winning games in one collection.

Portal: Companion Collection brings two of the most influential puzzle games to modern platforms, showcasing timeless design and sharp writing. While the games themselves are masterpieces, their original release dates keep this collection from ranking higher in a decade-focused list.

7. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom

The amazing sequel that brings new mechanics and exploration.

Tears of the Kingdom builds on the foundation of Breath of the Wild with expanded mechanics and creativity, especially through its building systems. While it improves on many aspects, it doesn’t quite recapture the same sense of originality, placing it slightly lower despite its impressive design.

6. Elden Ring

The critically acclaimed open-world RPG from the creators of Dark Souls.

Elden Ring successfully translates the challenging design of FromSoftware’s previous titles into a vast open world. Its sense of discovery and freedom is remarkable, though its narrative is more subtle and less direct than others on this list. Its impact and scale secure its place in the top ten.

5. The House in Fata Morgana - Dreams of the Revenants Edition

This visual novel brings a unique blend of mystery and adventure.

The House in Fata Morgana earns its place through its deeply emotional and intricately layered storytelling. Its narrative unfolds in a way that constantly recontextualizes what the player knows, leading to a powerful and unforgettable experience. Its more niche format keeps it from ranking higher, but its storytelling quality rivals the very best.

4. Baldur's Gate 3

This is a fantasy RPG that allows players to create their own character and make choices that affect the story.

Baldur’s Gate 3 represents the peak of player-driven RPG design, offering unmatched choice and reactivity. Every decision feels meaningful, and the sheer number of possibilities is staggering. It ranks just outside the top three due to a slightly less focused overall narrative, but its ambition and execution are undeniable.

3. Super Mario Odyssey

A huge open-world platformer with incredible creativity

Super Mario Odyssey stands as one of the most refined and joyful platformers ever created. Its creativity, tight controls, and constant introduction of new ideas make it endlessly engaging. While it doesn’t aim for the emotional or narrative depth of higher entries, its near-perfect gameplay design earns it a top-tier placement.

2. Red Dead Redemption 2

A story-driven Western adventure that will make you screem "YEE-HAW!"

Red Dead Redemption 2 earns second place through its unmatched level of detail and storytelling ambition. Its world feels alive in a way few games achieve, and Arthur Morgan’s character arc is one of the most powerful in gaming. While its pacing can be slow, that deliberate approach allows its narrative and immersion to reach incredible heights.

1. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Proof they did it right the first time

Breath of the Wild takes the top spot for completely redefining open-world design. Its emphasis on player freedom, discovery, and emergent gameplay created an experience where every player’s journey feels unique. Rather than guiding you, it trusts you to explore, experiment, and learn naturally. Its influence on the industry and its near-perfect execution make it the defining game of the decade.

Game Metascore User Score Available On
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 97 8.9 Switch
Red Dead Redemption 2 97 9.0 PC, PlayStation, Xbox
Super Mario Odyssey 97 8.9 Switch
Baldur's Gate 3 96 9.2 PC, PlayStation, Xbox
The House in Fata Morgana - Dreams of the Revenants Edition 96 7.1 PlayStation, Switch
Elden Ring 96 8.4 PC, PlayStation, Xbox
Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom 96 8.8 Switch
Portal: Companion Collection 95 8.7 Switch
Hades II 95 8.6 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch
Persona 5 Royal 95 8.8 PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch
↑ Top